Review Process
Learn about our comprehensive five-step review process and the five product categories that guide our reviewers.
Review Categories
Product reviews focus on five categories of product attributes.
Existence and quality of product attributes that promote equitable outcomes for Black, Latino/Latina, Indigenous students, and students from low-income backgrounds.
View the rubricResearch used to inform the design of the digital learning product is transparent and considers student populations by race and income.
The digital learning product uses equity-minded language.
Learning activities can be customized to embed culturally responsive and affirming functionalities.
Research is transparent and includes student outcomes evidence by race and income (e.g., case studies, quasi-experimental studies, experimental studies).
Students are consistently included and positively reflected.
The digital learning tool centers social, emotional, and academic supports that are culturally relevant and responsive, providing an affirming sense of belonging.
Existence and quality of research that supports a product’s effectiveness in improving students’ learning outcomes.
View the rubricSupplier-generated case studies and qualitative studies are available across a variety of use cases and contexts.
Research is conducted across a diversity of institutional settings, and outcomes data is disaggregated across those institutional setting types.
Suppliers’ research designs and supports are available for institutions interested in pursuing research based on product-generated data.
Available research supports a product’s efficacy and leverages reliable and valid empirical methods.
Research has been conducted by a trusted third party (e.g., a nationally recognized research organization or a qualified researcher who is peer-reviewed).
Existence and quality of product attributes that relate to instructional design and user experience.
View the rubricThe tool adjusts the presentations of content in relation to the knowledge of learners.
Students can engage with peers, mentors, or instructors as appropriate within the tool’s interface.
Instructors or course designers can alter the learning or assessment content.
The tool supports evidence-based teaching pedagogies such as active learning.
Includes support to help learners grow beyond their current level of proficiency.
Learning can be assessed in relation to learning objectives/competencies.
Software and user-centered design features support sustained engagement and high user satisfaction (across both single sittings and the entire course).
Technical components that indicate systems compatibility, ease of implementation, and data management capabilities.
View the rubricEasy-to-use and robust functionality allows users to create, store, and share course-related content in various formats.
Scheduling, progress support, and assignments are supported functions.
Data generated and stored by the supplier is easily available to relevant faculty and administrators upon their request.
Students' data is protected by third-party vendors and used for educational purposes.
View the rubricData is used in a positive and responsible way to promote data equity and ethical data uses.
Students’ data is protected, and students can decide how their data is to be shared, with no gap for Black, Latino/Latina, Indigenous students, and students from low-income backgrounds.
Reliance on third-party applications is limited, does not inhibit student learning or use, and the implications of third-party relationships are clearly outlined to students, instructors, and administrators.
Governance Board
The CourseGateway Governance Board provides guidance and strategic oversight to ensure the product review process is aligned with the overall mission and goals of the CourseGateway program. It is populated by previous members of the Product Advisory Board.
Program Director, Personalized Adaptive Learning (PAL)
Director of Faculty Development and Online Education, Associate Professor of Criminal Justice
Associate Dean and Professor of Management
Director Adaptive & Personalized Learning, EdPlus Design & Development
Associate Professor, English and Modern Foreign Languages
Product Advisory Board
Product reviews are performed by an independent Product Advisory Board established specifically for the purposes of CourseGateway. View our current Product Advisory Board on the EDUCAUSE website.
The CourseGateway Story
Learn more about the CourseGateway mission and our vision for more equitable outcomes through student-centered digital learning experiences.
READ OUR STORY